subscribe to our newsletter

Mortgage redraws leave borrowers ‘worse off’: RateCity

According to new research, consumers that consolidate a car loan into their mortgage are “worse off”.

RateCity research has reported that using a mortgage offset or redraw facility to fund a car purchase could cost consumers tens of thousands of dollars if extra repayments are not made.

According to the loan comparison site’s data, while the average interest rate on a home loan (4.30 per cent) is lower than that of a car loan (8.31 per cent), borrowers could pay more than double the price of the principal on their car purchase if the vehicle is paid off over the life span of a mortgage.

According to RateCity, if a $30,000 car loan is paid off over 25 years, the consumer would pay a total of $77,710 for their car, with $47,710 being interest.

In contrast, RateCity’s research revealed that if a consumer paid an 8.31 per cent interest rate on a car loan of the same amount over five years, they would pay $6,769 in interest ($36,769 in total).


Further, if opting to finance their car purchase while making extra repayments through a mortgage redraw, consumers would pay $3,393 over five years on an interest rate of 4.30 per cent.

“Too often, people dip into their mortgages with little thought to the long-term consequences,” RateCity money editor Sally Tindall said.

“Compounding interest can leave a nasty sting in the tail if you take the money out of your mortgage and never get around to topping it back up.”

Findings are 'partly inaccurate' says finance broker

However, finance broker and principal of asset finance company Astute Ability Group Mhairi MacLeod told Mortgage Business that the research is partly “inaccurate”.


Ms MacLeod noted that based on her calculations, the total interest paid on a mortgage redraw for a $30,000 car loan over 25 years is much lower than the $47,710 figure reported by RateCity. 

“If you look at mortgage redraw over 25 years, the actual total interest is $19,009, with the total costs of the car being $49,009,” Ms MacLeod said. 

Ms MacLeod added that nine out of 10 borrowers don’t make extra repayments on their car loan and instead opt to repay their debt incrementally.

“Most [clients] whack it on the home loan, forget about it and end up paying the additional $19,009,” the principal added. 

“[The] failures are in human nature. If they don’t have to make the extra repayment, they won’t do it.”

Ms MacLeod also noted that interest payable on a car loan can be reduced without forcing a consumer to consolidate debt through their mortgage.

“You’ve got to bear in mind, too, that the total amount of interest payable on a secured car loan or on a personal loan can be reduced,” Ms MacLeod said. “So, depending on a lender and depending on where it sits, you can actually reduce that total amount of interest payable.”

Ms Tindall, however, advised consumers to avoid compounded interest by making regular principal payments on their loan.

“If you take money out of your offset account or redraw facility, make sure you put the money back, as soon as humanly possible,” the money editor said.

“The best way to do this is to set up an automatic payment, similar to what you would have paid if you’d taken out a car loan.”

[Related:  ‘Major flaw’ with mortgage comparison rates, says CEO]

Mortgage redraws leave borrowers ‘worse off’: RateCity

Are you a new-to-industry broker in the process of growing your business? Then there’s some great news: The Adviser’s New Broker Academy is back in 2021 and will provide you with essential insights into cutting-edge tools, strategies and processes to fast-track to success. Don’t miss your chance to attend. To secure your FREE place, visit newbroker.com.au now!

Charbel Kadib

Charbel Kadib is the news editor on the mortgages titles at Momentum Media.

Before joining the team in 2017, Charbel completed internships with public relations agency Fifty Acres, and the Department of Communications and the Arts.

You can email Charbel on: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Latest News

Reverse mortgage lenders have accessed a small fraction of the potential retiree housing market in Australia, according to Deloitte. ...

Pepper Money has priced its second I-Prime deal for the year, upsizing the figure to $850 million. ...

The LMI provider has announced a new CFO following the resignation of its current CFO, effective 24 September. ...

Join Australia's most informed brokers

Do you know which lenders are providing brokers and their customers with the best service?

Use this monthly data to make informed decisions about which lenders to use. Simply contribute to the survey and we'll send you the results directly to your inbox - completely free!

How long do you think it should take to discharge a mortgage?

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.