subscribe to our newsletter

Raising fines key to limiting misconduct occurrence

Raising the private cost of “bad behaviour” for companies is key to deterring it, the chair of the ACCC has said.

Speaking at the National Consumer Data Policy Research Centre on Friday, chair of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) Rod Sims remarked how “appalling” he finds it that banks have knowingly engaged in “inappropriate” behaviour because “they would lose out to their competitors if they did not”.

“I find such an approach, both by bankers and electricity retailers, appalling. Then you hear senior business executives express surprise at how they and their behaviour are perceived by the community,” Mr Sims lamented.

Mr Sims referred to remuneration structures that reward employees for reaching or exceeding certain targets, acknowledging that despite them being a “legitimate and effective way of encouraging sales teams”, they could lead to poor customer outcomes if “proper safeguards are not established to limit how staff or agents achieve their sales targets”.

The chair mentioned the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, which showcased some of the negative consequences driven, at least in part, by problematic financial incentives. He further praised the efforts of activists in identifying and shining a light on bad behaviour, which Mr Sims believes is necessary to deter such behaviour in the future.


“Bad behaviour by a company can undermine its brand reputation. The greater the likelihood that bad behaviour will be exposed and made public, the more companies will do to guard against such behaviours,” the ACCC chair explained.

“A key value of the royal commission has been to expose the poor behaviour of financial institutions to public scrutiny. The evidence about the conduct of AMP was particularly damning. The resulting damage to AMP’s brand reputation has been substantial.”

Referring to businesses more broadly, Mr Sims suggested that regulators need to do more to “internalise” the negative consequences of inappropriate behaviour, as the incentives for misconduct are stronger than the penalties for misconduct.

As such, the ACCC chair has urged the Parliament to pass a bill to increase penalties for breach of the Australian Consumer Law and the Competition and Consumer Act 2010. Specifically, the ACCC would like the $1.1 million fine for breaching the Australian Consumer Law to be increased to either $10 million, three times the gains generated from misconduct or 10 per cent of a company’s annual revenues.

“Just imagine if the penalties we have achieved recently were 10 to 20 times higher. Then perhaps some companies would not be behaving so badly. And then, when they say they put their customers first, it might have more validity than it does today,” Mr Sims said.


More regulation can be “harmful”

The chair acknowledged, however, that more regulation can “often be harmful to consumers”, particularly in industries that are already heavily regulated such as financial services. He referenced the banning of late fees and overdue payments in the energy sector, which then prompted providers to introduce “pay-on-time discounts”, making the “full price” of the bill large in comparison to the discounted early fee and larger than the previous fees charged for late payments.

“And this is just one example of a perverse policy outcome,” Mr Sims said.

A similar sentiment was communicated by Federal Treasurer Scott Morrison, who warned last month that the government’s response to the financial services royal commission will need to be careful not to “create a self-fulfilling problem” by creating “unnecessary regulation” that “suffocates the economy”.

Many mortgage industry players and economists have also noted the challenges of overregulation, including reduced credit availability to customers. For example, Semper Capital director Andrew Way argued that any increase in regulations that result in limiting the rights in default of lenders providing loans to small business is going to have an adverse effect on lending to small businesses.

In its recent report, titled Credit Crunch? Seven factors to consider, UBS stated that the royal commission’s “rigorous interpretation” of responsible lending is resulting in banks more critically assessing borrowers’ incomes and living expenses, which will continue to impact credit availability.

UBS also cautioned in a report to its customers earlier this year that a tightening of mortgage lending standards will have a “material impact on the economy”, noting that property prices are not dictated by the demand for and supply of housing, but rather the demand for and supply of credit.

[Related: Consumer Data Right to improve mortgage process: ACCC]

Raising fines key to limiting misconduct occurrence

Tas Bindi

Tas Bindi is the features editor on the mortgage titles and writes about the mortgage industry, macroeconomics, fintech, financial regulation, and market trends.  

Prior to joining Momentum Media, Tas wrote for business and technology titles such as ZDNet, TechRepublic, Startup Daily, and Dynamic Business. 

You can email Tas on: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.



Latest News

The big four bank has confirmed that it is rolling out a new program of work to increase the speed in which it provides unconditional approv...

The ASBFEO has called on government to fund a revenue-contingent loan scheme for SMEs to help them manage cash flow once support measures en...

The fintech’s debit card and pay facilities will come offline today following the neobank’s decision to exit the banking business. ...


Join a group of highly informed brokers.

Broker Pulse, a community-driven knowledge base of lender performance Reveal exactly which lenders are making life easiest for brokers and their clients by taking this monthly survey and joining a group of highly informed brokers who leverage these insights every month.


LATEST PODCAST: A new mortgage lender enters the fray

Do you expect to see strong uptake of the HomeBuilder scheme?

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.